With Penguins C Sidney Crosby, last year’s runaway MVP missing 21 games this season due to a high-ankle sprain, the race for the Hart Trophy is turning into an interesting one. A legitimate case can be made for at least eight to ten players this year and maybe more. Injuries to key players such as Dany Heatley, Mike Richards, Paul Stastny, and Crosby, who may have received consideration at the point of their injuries, unfortunately will not be factors this season.
The age-old debate also comes into play though on whether or not a player who’s team does not make the playoffs should be considered. But think of it this way – Even if a team misses the playoffs while only winning 25-30 games, you have to consider just how important a player was in helping a miserable team even get to that point.
The following is a list of players whom I feel merit MVP consideration, in order of how I see the voting play out;
1. ALEX OVECHKIN (WAS) – The human highlight reel leads the NHL with 54 goals and 95 points. He will no doubt win the Rocket Richard Trophy as the league’s top goal scorer with the next closest player (Kovalchuk) at 45. Ovechkin has been in on 47 percent of Washington’s goals and has been the single reason they are fighting for a playoff berth. Leads league in PPG with 18 and GWG with nine. No team relies so heavily on one player like the Caps rely on Ovechkin.
2. EVGENI MALKIN (PIT) – Currently battling Ovechkin for league scoring title with 92 points. With Crosby out for 21 games, Malkin put the Penguins on his back and currently has them in a battle for the Atlantic division lead as well as the Eastern Conference. Malkin had 36 points in those 21 games as the Pens went 11-6-4 without Crosby.
3. MARTIN BRODEUR (NJ) – After the Devils started the season on a tough 9-game road trip (3-5-1), Brodeur has led New Jersey to a 40-23-6 record. The Devils are 26th in the NHL in goals scored (180) which proves just how valuable Brodeur has been this season. He is the only goaltender in the top 5 of most major statistics as he currently ranks second in wins (38), games played (64) and save percentage (.922), third in GAA (2.12), and fifth in shutouts (4).
4. JAROME IGINLA (CAL) – After a tough start to the season (10-13-4 in first 27 games), Iginla has led the Flames back into a battle for the Northwest division title. His 40 goals rank third in the NHL and he sits fifth in overall scoring with 79 points. Iginla has been in on 42 percent of Flames scoring and leads the team (6th in NHL) with a plus 25 rating. Tied with Ovechkin for league lead in GWG with nine.
5. JOE THORNTON (SJ) – Consistently amongst the league leaders in assists and points from year to year, Thornton is currently tied for the lead in the NHL with 62 assists and fourth in scoring with 81 points. His Sharks are currently one point out of first place in the tough Pacific division and have the NHL’s best road record at 24-8-3. Thornton also has 32 more points than the next closest Shark in recently acquired D Brian Campbell (49).
6. PAVEL DATSYUK (DET) – Playing on a team as deep in talent as Detroit will not make it easy for Datsyuk to gain many votes for the Hart Trophy but one cannot ignore his statistical contributions for the NHL’s first pace Red Wings. Currently he sits seventh in league scoring with 79 points, third in assists with 54, and second in plus/minus with a plus 33 rating.
7. DANIEL ALFREDSSON (OTT) – Ottawa captain Daniel Alfredsson leads the struggling Sens in goals (37), points (79), short-handed goals (7), and shots (198). His 1.32 PPG ranks only behind Crosby (1.37) and Ovechkin (1.36). While the big three for Ottawa have missed chunks of play due to injury combined with goaltending issues and a coaching change, Alfredsson has been the most consistent in keeping the Sens in a battle for the Northeastern division lead with Montreal.
8. ALEX KOVALEV (MTL) – The Montreal Canadiens are currently atop the Northeast division and second in the Eastern conference – in large part due to the play of Kovalev. He has 30 goals and 73 points and is on pace for his second best point total for his career. His 42 PP points are tops in the NHL and his Habs also lead the league on the PP with a 24.8% success rate.
9. RYAN GETZLAF (ANA) – Getzlaf is far and away the offensive leader on a solid Ducks team that is in a battle for the Pacific division title but who do not score many goals (176). His 72 points have him contributing to 41 percent of Anaheim’s scoring. He is tied for the fifth highest total in the NHL with 51 assists and is seventh in the league with a plus 24 rating.
10. MARC SAVARD (BOS) – His 62 assists is tied with Joe Thornton for the league lead and is 13 points higher than teammate Marco Sturm’s point total. He is 11th in league scoring with 76 points and a fixture on the Bruins power play. Without Savard, the eight other Bruins with 10+ goals may not be having such productive seasons. Boston currently sits seventh in the East.
Honourable mention goes to;
11. EVGENI NABOKOV (SJ) – Besides Brodeur is as valuable a goalie as there is in the NHL. Ranks first in the league in games played (66), and wins (39), third in shutouts (6), and sixth in GAA (2.19).
12. VINCENT LECAVALIER/MARTIN ST. LOUIS (TB) – Despite the fact that Lecavalier sits third (81 points) and St. Louis 15th (73 points) in league scoring, the two high scoring forwards will unfortunately not garner enough attention for MVP voting due in large part to; A> their last place standing in the Eastern conference, and; B> their dismal minus-7 and minus-11 ratings respectively.
13. JASON SPEZZA (OTT) – Even after missing a handful of games due to injury sits eighth in league scoring with 78 points.
14. HENRIK ZETTERBERG (DET) – Currently ninth in league scoring with 77 points, Zetterberg will suffer the same fate as teammate Pavel Datsyuk while playing on a team deep in talent.
15. MIKE RIBEIRO (DAL) – Sits 13th in league scoring with 75 points as his Dallas Stars are tops in the tough Pacific division and second in the Western conference. Also 12th in the league in assists (48) and plus/minus at plus-22.
16. MATS SUNDIN (TOR) – Other than Vesa Toskala, Sundin is the lone bright spot most nights on a Leafs team which will miss the playoffs for the third consecutive season. Currently 12th in league scoring with 75 points.
17. ILYA BRYZGALOV (PHX) – Since the Coyotes claimed Bryzgalov off waivers from the Anaheim Ducks, their season has been turned around. He has posted a record of 23-17-4 and helped climb Phoenix to within striking distance of a playoff position.
18. ILYA KOVALCHUK (ATL) – Kovalchuk is second in the NHL with 45 goals but has not been consistent enough to help the Thrashers make a push towards the playoffs. His minus-12 rating is also unappealing to voters but has had very little offensive help this season.